How Screwed is Penn Badgley’s Jeff Buckley Movie?
Eyebrows have been raised since Penn Badgley, clean-cut star of Gossip Girl, signed up to play a pre-fame Jeff Buckley in Greetings From Tim Buckley, one of three planned upcoming movies about the late troubadour. Yesterday, though, things got even more worrisome for Greetings: Director Jake Scott, who’s developing his own, as-yet-untitled Buckley biopic — one with actual rights to the singer’s songs — including (boom!) his cover of Leonard Cohen’s “Hallelujah” — just cast Reeve Carney.
That name, admittedly, might not immediately elicit positive vibes. If you know Carney at all, it’s probably for his work as Peter Parker in Broadway’s cursed-but-still-kicking Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark. But! Important fact No. 1: unlike Badgley, who’s vowed to take vocal lessions to play Buckley, Carney already knows how to sing. He does so, both in Spider-Man and in his ingeniously named band Carney (in which he also plays guitar), and in a manner not wholly dissimilar to that of Jeff Buckley. Important fact No. 2: Look at him! Those cheekbones, the tousled hair, the general mid-hangover facial expression: he already looks pretty much exactly like Buckley.
Just in case you needed audiovisual proof that Greetings might be in trouble, here it is. This is Badgley singing to a baby in an episode of Gossip Girl:
… and here’s Carney doing “Bohemian Rhapsody” at a concert in 2007:
Badgley’s best hope: that the Australian producers of A Pure Drop, a third purportedly upcoming Buckley movie, cast someone even worse.
More from Amos Barshad
More Hollywood Prospectus
“Probably ‘Smokin Aces’, because it wasn’t my hair, and it was like, long beautiful hair that I could never grow.” … “Yeah. I take a supplement called Viviscal. And it’s supposed to help speed up your hair growth. And I really think it works, because my beard grows really fast and I have to get a haircut once a week while using it.” —Ask Jeremy Piven Anything About His Hair